A Million Little Opinions
Just - and I mean just, like in the last hour - finished reading "A Million Little Pieces", the now-controversial book that might be a memoir or might be a highly stylized work of fiction based on real events. If you haven't kept track of the controversy, one of a million different places to start reading might be here.
First off, it's a great and searing read. It's a great story, no doubt. But isn't there something about promoting a book as a memoir that requires a level of honesty and accuracy? And do we know for sure that the book is liberal in its use of exaggerations and untruths? For me, I say no - we don't really know how much is true, but obviously some questions have been raised. Still, I think that there is a level of accuracy and integrity required of memoirs and documentaries that isn't required of other works. And if the author (or director, in the case of documentary filmmaking) breaches the line between truth and fiction, it's proper to call that out. It seems to me that this whole controversy would have been avoided if the publisher and/or author had promoted the book as a narrative based on real events - as opposed to promoting it as a memoir.
But now, to a different issue: The book details Frey's stay at a rehab clinic. According to his description, the clinic in question holds that the 12-step method to addiction recovery is the only viable methodology available today. (Please note: I have no way to comment on their position. I'm just not informed enough to weigh in on that debate.) But Frey rejects the 12-step method and chooses to base his ultimate recovery on his own day-by-day rejection of alcohol and drugs. I'm not an expert - or even a marginally informed layman - with regard to addiction. But I do wonder if his rejection of the method (which seems to be based on his distaste for its avowed reliance upon God or a loosely defined "Higher Power") will lead others who have perhaps less will power to try his same method. And if they do fail there where they might have succeeded in a 12-step context, does he bear some blame? Honestly, I think the answer is probably that he doesn't, because people are responsible for whatever decisions they make, foolish or otherwise. But it's interesting to think about.
I'm sure that others on the blog will have interesting thoughts on the topic, so I post a loose question to y'all: whaddya think?