Um, No, That's Jazz
Heard today that Miles Davis will be inducted into the RnRHOF. Now, I'm gonna stand on a soap box for a sec here. This is an area of which I will humbly claim some expertise. Most things in the world I'm pretty confused about. Music? I've got cred in this area.
This is not complicated. Miles Davis was not, ever, never, wasn't, never was, never claimed to be, a rock musician. Wasn't. Was. Not.
Jazz. He played jazz. Trumpet. Jazz trumpet.
Brilliant, yes. Visionary, yes. Genius, yes. Changed music, yes. Irreplaceble in the pantheon of all musical history, yes. Indespensable as a writer, yes. Remarkable eye for talent, yes. 50 years of top-line performing, yes.
Not rock. Not.
And don't give me that shit about Bitches Brew, cause it ain't a rock record. Rock journalists love to say shit like, "Bitches Brew melded jazz and rock in a way that had never been done before or since, and Miles had his finger on the pulse of what was happening in both jazz and rock and captured the essence of rock from a jazz framework." Pablum, by the way, and bullshit. It's a fusion record. Fine. Rock, it is not.
Miles listened to Jimi Hendrix. Fine. So did everyone. Just 'cause he liked Jimi, doesn't mean he's a rock musician. Still jazz. He made a fusion record. Fine. Still jazz. Changed much of modern music. Fine. Still jazz. Embraced pop music throughout his career by covering everything from Broadway showtunes in the 50s to Cindi Lauper tunes in the 80s. Fine. Jazz.
I haven't read the press releases about this, so I'm on record right now with disagreeing with the press release before knowing it's content. They're wrong.
Feel free to post the press release and make your arguments in the comments. I'm on my soapbox. Jazz. Not rock. Jazz.
Line up your soapbox if you dare.